City Council

Agenda Request

Agenda Of:

12/05/06

Agenda Request No:

V B

Initiated By:

Keisha E. Seals, engineer ii

Responsible Department:

engineering

Presented By:

Patrick Walsh, P.E., Interim City Engineer

Department Head:

Patrick Walsh, P.E., Interim City Engineer

 

 

Additional Department. Head (s):

 

Subject / Proceeding:

Contract for Dulles Avenue Preliminary Engineering Study; Consideration and Action

Exhibits:

Attachment C, scope of Services

(hard copy of complete contract available)

Clearances

Approval

Legal:

Meredith Wilganowski,

Assistant City Attorney

Executive Director:

jim callaway

community development

Purchasing:

 

Asst. City Manager:

n/a

Budget:

Jennifer Brown

Assistant Fiscal Services Director

City Manager:

Allen Bogard/ab

Budget

Expenditure Required:  $

149,994.18

Amount Budgeted/Reallocation:  $

195,000.00 (ST0401); UNENCUMBERED BALANCE IN ST0401 IS $157,500.00

Additional Appropriation:  $

n/a

Recommended Action

Engineering staff recommends approval of a contract with CLR, Inc. for preliminary engineering services for the Dulles Avenue expansion.


 

Executive Summary

In 2002, a Dulles/Kirkwood thoroughfare study was prepared to identify improvements to reduce traffic congestion along the Dulles corridor.  Several improvements were identified and further study was recommended.  The anticipated improvements include a curb and gutter facility between U.S. 90A and Avenue “E” with additional turn lane capacity at specific locations.  The study also recommended an expansion from four (4) to six (6) lanes for a short section of Dulles between S.H. 6 and Cartwright Road, and additional southbound right turn lane capacity in front of Dulles High School.

The City subsequently worked with other agencies to obtain funding for a preliminary engineering study for Dulles. In October of 2004, Council approved an Advanced Funding Agreement (AFA) with the Texas Department of Transportation (TxDOT).   The City also entered into an agreement with Fort Bend County to share the local funding match for the study.  The anticipated cost of the study was $150,000.  Through these agreements, funding for the preliminary engineering study has been appropriated as follows:

Ø      $112,500 representing 75% of the anticipated $150,000 to be provided by TxDOT,

Ø      $18,750 representing 12.5% funded by the City as half of the required 25% local match, and appropriated in the FY04 Capital Improvement Program, and

Ø      $18,750 representing 12.5% funded by Fort Bend County representing the other half of the local match. 

 

The City, working in coordination with TxDOT, issued a request for qualifications (RFQ) in 2005 and completed a formal process to select a consultant to provide preliminary engineering services for Dulles Avenue.  Fort Bend County, City of Missouri City, and City of Stafford participated in the selection committee.   CLR, Inc. was selected based on their scoring on numerous factors, including prior similar work experience, performance with TxDOT projects, and staff qualifications.  Once a consultant was selected, the City and TxDOT began an extensive scoping and contract review and audit process.  In September of 2006, TxDOT approved the contract between the City and CLR allowing the City to proceed with the execution of the contract (please see attached scope of services for the consultant).

 

This study will consist of preliminary engineering for the development of a final alternative for Dulles Avenue, from U.S. Hwy 90A to S.H. 6, a length of approximately 3.2 miles.  The primary elements of the study include the following:

 

·        A traffic analysis including identification of turn lane locations

·        Assessment of pedestrian facilities and needs

·        Public involvement process

·        Drainage study

·        Environmental study

·        Identification of right-of-way requirements

·        Cost estimate

 

A noise study for this project is not included.  Upon inquiries of the City, TxDOT has indicated that since this project does not include additional thru lane capacity on Dulles, it does not qualify for a noise study or construction of sound walls. 

 

Adequate funds for this preliminary engineering study are available in CIP ST0401, Dulles Avenue.  TxDOT has already committed to reimbursement of invoices via the 2004 agreement.   This preliminary engineering study is anticipated to be complete by mid-2007.

 

The 2007-2011 Capital Improvement Program (C.I.P.) included funds in FY08 for design in the amount of $575,000.  The construction cost is estimated at approximately $7,770,000.

 

The preliminary engineering study will further refine the anticipated design and construction costs.  The funding plan for the project is continuing to be refined with time.  However, some planning has already been completed towards the funding of this project, as follows:

 

Ø      Approximately $3.3 million in federal funds have already been successfully obtained through the Houston-Galveston Area Council’s (H-GAC) Transportation Improvement Program (T.I.P.),

Ø      The voters in Fort Bend County approved $1.55 million in general obligation bonds through the 2000 mobility bond referendum.  Some of this funding may be used for design of the project;

Ø      The City may request that additional funds be included in the Fort Bend County’s next bond referendum, anticipated in May 2007.  Preliminarily, this amount may be as much as $4.29 million;

Ø      The City recently requested additional funding in the 2008-2011 T.I.P.;

Ø      City of Sugar Land will likely need to fund a local match to federal and county funding.  Early estimates placed this match at up to $490,000;

Ø      Sugar Land will investigate the potential for Missouri City and Stafford to financially participate in the project as well, potentially through an equal match with Sugar Land’s participation. 

 

Once the preliminary engineering study is completed, the next phase of the project will be the design engineering and construction.    Design for the project is anticipated to be completed in 2008, with construction completed in 2009 or 2010, as funding is secured.

 

Exhibits

 


ATTACHMENT C

SERVICES TO BE PROVIDED BY THE ENGINEER

 

Preliminary Engineering/Categorical Exclusion

Scope of Work Outline

Dulles Avenue – US 90A to SH 6

CSJ 0912-34-108

CIP Project ST0401

 

Background

A Dulles/Kirkwood thoroughfare study was prepared by others for the City of Sugar Land, City of Missouri City, and Stafford in 2002. Traffic counts obtained for the study were used for the analysis. Improvements to reduce traffic congestion were recommended in the study. Further study is needed to refine the recommended improvements and determine the construction cost, right-of-way requirements, and obtain environmental clearance.

 

Scope of Work

FHWA, the City of Sugar Land, and Fort Bend County are sharing in the funding of this study. Federal funding will be sought for construction, therefore TxDOT criteria shall be used for the design. The following improvements recommended in the previous study shall be further defined in this scope of work:

1)      Add southbound turn lane in front of the schools between US 90A and Avenue E. Consider both open ditch and curb and gutter roadway section. A raised median and continuous turn lane will be considered as well.  Section should include a sidewalk on both sides of the street  between US 90A and Avenue E.

2)      Add a northbound and southbound turn lane between Cartwright Road and SH 6.

3)      Analyze major intersections (Avenue E, Lexington, Cartwright, and SH 6) to determine where intersection improvements improve traffic flow and are cost effective.

The work to be performed by the Engineer shall consist of preliminary engineering for the development of a diagrammatic layout of Dulles Avenue from US 90A to SH 6 in Fort Bend County, Texas and associated Categorical Exclusion. The length of this project is approximately 3.2 miles. The deliverables under this contract shall be alternative sections, diagrammatic layout of the preferred alternative, drainage letter report, engineering summary letter, Categorical Exclusion, and limited topographic survey.

The Engineer will prepare a detailed diagrammatic layout of the recommended preferred alternative, which will include plan and profile data and typical sections. The Engineer will conduct one public meeting. The City will publish a Notice for Public Meeting.

TASK 1 – ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS

1.1       Develop Base Maps

The base maps to be used for the alternative analysis shall consist of readily available Digital Ortho Quarter Quads (DOQQ’s) and available USGS mapping.

1.2       Analyze Existing Conditions

Using the assembled data and base maps developed, an overall analysis of the existing conditions and features must be studied for:

1.       Right-of-way determination

2.       Horizontal Alignment

3.       Existing pavement structure, cross-sections (review pavement width, number of lanes and turn lane locations)

4.       Intersection configuration (review turn lane storage and traffic controls)

5.       Traffic counts from previous study and HGAC modeling data (no new traffic counts will be collected).

6.       Accident locations

7.       Critical Locations (field observations of critical locations during peak periods of traffic)

8.       Drainage, establish profile to determine drainage deficiencies          

1.3               Traffic Analysis

1.                   The Engineer shall grow the existing traffic data to opening date (assumed 2010 as opening year) traffic utilizing growth rates provided by HGAC as well as 20-years beyond for use in the EA.

2.                   The Engineer shall review the accident data along the corridor for the latest 3 years.

3.                   The Engineer will model proposed lane configurations and projected traffic volumes to develop number and storage length of turn lanes at major intersections (Avenue E, Lexington, Cartwright, and SH 6).

 

1.4       Right of Entry

It will be the responsibility of the Engineer to determine ownership data and secure permission to enter private property for purposes of survey and environmental investigations.  Digital tax maps provided by the County will be used to identify landowners.  A right-of-entry (ROE) letter will be prepared on State or City letterhead and mailed to each property owner in the study area.  A written response will be requested either confirming or denying ROE.  The Engineer will make reasonable attempts to contact each landowner verbally prior to conducting any fieldwork if written correspondence is not successful.  A log of all contact with landowners will be maintained.

1.5 Utility Inventory. For each reasonable alternative, summarize the major utilities present within the corridor (major transmission lines only).  The information is to include type, length, size, company name, and address. Scope does not include identification or mapping of minor utilities to include but not limited to buried cables, waterlines, and sanitary sewer.

 

1.6       Alternatives Analysis

The Engineer shall identify maximum of three reasonable alignment alternatives to minimize potential adverse impacts, major utility conflicts, structural impediments, or exceptions to TxDOT or FHWA design criteria. Using the information obtained for the environmental work as a planning tool, the Engineer will develop maximum of three alternative concepts. The aerial maps and alternative sections will be utilized for exhibits at the public meeting. The Alternatives Analysis will include:

1.                  Develop drawings showing corridor footprint based on maximum ROW width and intersection configurations.

2.                  Identify turn bay locations and length of turn lane.

3.                  Establish preliminary horizontal alignments.

4.                  Develop preliminary typical sections.

5.                  Establish 100-year floodplain elevations and floodway limits at major stream crossings using available existing data (FEMA Flood Boundary Maps, existing drainage studies).

6.                  Determine approximate right-of-way requirements based on preliminary typical sections.

7.                  All existing traffic data will be provided by the HGAC, from previous studies performed by others, or by the City of Sugar Land.

8.                  Prepare preliminary cost estimates for the construction of each alternative utilizing TxDOT’s latest unit cost per lane mile.

9.                  Prepare preliminary estimate of right-of-way costs.

 

1.7   Public Involvement on Alternatives

The Engineer will conduct a public involvement process that will include informing the public about the project and soliciting public input to the process.  The public involvement program will include one public meeting in the study area, presentation to Sugar Land City council, presentation to Fort Bend Commissioner’s court, and small group meetings with local officials.  The proposed public involvement program will employ the follow­ing methods for the exchange of information:

1.   Small Group Meetings – Throughout the project, meetings with small groups from within the local community will be held if requested.  The Engineer will provide a two‑person team for each of these meetings to informally discuss the project.  All requests for such meetings will be coordinated with the State and City prior to establishing a meeting date and time.  The local organization will be responsible for providing the meeting location and contacting their members.  For budget purposes, two such meetings are planned.  The Engineer will prepare and submit Small Group Meeting minutes for each meeting.

2.       Public Meeting

a.       The Engineer will locate and arrange facilities for the public meeting. The public will be notified in advance of the meeting through the use of newspaper advertisements. The Engineer will prepare the notice and provide to the City. The City will arrange for publishing in local newspaper. The Engineer will prepare and release a press notice through the City regarding the meeting.  Public meeting notices will be mailed (on City or State letterhead) to interested parties, government officials (local, state and federal) and all adjacent property owners

b.       The Engineer will conduct one public meeting in the project area to inform the public of the progress of the study and to obtain public input. The Engineer shall provide public meeting displays and meeting materials.  All public concerns and comments identified during the meeting will be noted.  A set of comments will be compiled and the mailing list updated.

  1. The Engineer will prepare and submit a public meeting report (four copies) to address the substantive comments made at the public meeting.  This report will contain the following information:

a.       Copies of sign-in sheets with names and addresses of the attendees

b.       Summary and analysis of the proceedings and comments received

c.       Discussion and tabulation of the written comments

d.       Copy of the program/agenda and any information that was distributed

e.       Reduced versions or photographs of the exhibits

 

Deliverables for Task 1

The following items will be completed for the project under the Task 1 scope of work:

1.                   ROE Log

2.                   Presentations to City Council and Commissioner’s Court

3.                   Public Meeting Report (four copies)

4.                   Conceptual Designs (ROW corridor) for maximum of three alternatives

5.                   Meeting with City, TxDOT, and Engineer after alternative analysis and public meeting to identify recommended preferred alternative.

TASK 2 – DEVELOP DIAGRAMMATIC LAYOUT

Using existing DOQQ mapping and available USGS data of Fort Bend County, and/or aerial survey, develop a diagrammatic layout for the preferred alternative and submit to the State and the City.

2.1            Diagrammatic

The Engineer will prepare a diagrammatic layout to a scale of 1”=100’. The diagrammatic will be prepared using the English system of units. The Engineer will revise, as needed, the centerline horizontal and vertical alignments of the appropriate conceptual design and submit to the City and State for approval.  All designs will be prepared in accordance with the latest versions of:  Roadway Design Manual (TxDOT), A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets (AASHTO), Standard Specifications for Construction of Highways, Streets and Bridges (TxDOT), Highway Operations Manual of the Traffic Operations Manual (TxDOT), and Highway Capacity Manual (Transportation Research Board).

In preparing the diagrammatic, the Engineer will:

1.       Establish a typical roadway section with preferred roadway type (curb and gutter).

2.       Calculate preliminary horizontal alignments.

3.       Calculate preliminary roadway profile based on the results of hydrologic and hydraulic investigation.

4.       Determine all property lines (based on records from the County tax appraisal district ).

5.       Identify major utilities and potential conflicts

6.       Prepare a brief narrative for each traffic control phase along with traffic control typical sections

7.       Determine right-of-way acreage and parcel identification.

8.       Establish the 100-year floodplain elevations and floodway limits at major stream crossings.

9.       Calculate preliminary earthwork volumes (using average end method) using the typical sections, and proposed roadway geometry.

10.   Prepare preliminary cost estimates using TxDOT bid items and current Houston District average unit prices. Sub-totals shall be shown for each area (ie drainage, signals, roadway, etc.). Include right-of-way costs (as separate item) in cost estimate.

The diagrammatic will be provided to the State and the City for review at the following stages of completion:

·                     Interim – Calculated horizontal and vertical alignments, typical sections, water surface elevations at major crossings, and identification of environmental and major utility conflicts.

·                     Final – Finalize interim submittal, intersections, preliminary ROW requirements, and sequence of construction

 

 

2.2       Hydrologic and Hydraulic Investigation

The following tasks shall be completed in the preparation of the roadway profile (recommended preferred alternative only):

1.                   Determine the existing and proposed drainage area boundaries based on the available data.

2.                   Identify existing outfalls.

3.                   Review available reports/studies prepared by others regarding flow characteristics of stream crossings.

4.                   Obtain the existing HEC-1 and HEC-2 models from applicable drainage authorities, to the extent possible, for use in analysis and determination of existing 2, 10, 25, 50 and 100-year water surface elevations at major water crossings. This data will be utilized in the development of the roadway profile.

5.                   Develop 2, 10, 25, 50, and 100 year frequency flows at each major crossing for existing and proposed conditions using standard TxDOT and Fort Bend  County hydrologic methodology.

6.                   Analyze the major existing cross culverts to develop existing tailwater and headwater conditions. Determine high water elevations for the 2, 10, 25, 50 and 100-year frequencies. Determine preliminary proposed outfall structure sizes using HEC-RAS. The report will also include preliminary sizing of the ditch, storm sewers and cross culverts within the limits of the project, conceptual and generic discussions of the alternatives considered, a comparative cost associated with each alternative and a recommended solution.

7.                   Superimpose WSE’s on profile drawing. The profile drawings will provide an overall view of the roadway and existing ground elevations with respect to the various design frequencies for the length of the entire project. This will enable the Engineer to determine the most feasible roadway profile.

8.                   The volume of flood plain water displaced from the proposed roadway improvements will be roughly determined as well as approximate estimate of the available on-site volume.

9.                   A 100-year sheet flow analysis will be prepared for the existing condition. A conceptual 100-year sheet flow analysis will be prepared for the proposed condition.

10.               Mitigation volumes will be roughly determined at each outfall for the project. Mitigation volumes will be determined by comparison of existing and proposed hydrographs developed using the Small Watershed Method.

11.               Coordination with any government agencies through TxDOT will be conducted in all phases of this study.

12.               Prepare a letter report summarizing the methodologies and findings of the hydrologic and hydraulic investigation. Study and analysis will be in accordance with Fort Bend County and TxDOT policies and practices. The letter report will be signed and sealed by a professional engineer. The results will be summarized and presented to the State and the City for discussion. The report will include exhibits, tables, and drainage calculations.

13.               A separate drainage study (PER) by others will be initiated as part of the City’s FY 06 CIP. This study will identify necessary ditch improvements to improve capacity restrictions at driveway-culvert crossings along Dulles Avenue. The study by others will provide interim drainage improvements prior to the reconstruction of Dulles Avenue.

14.               The findings from the study by others may be applicable to the overall roadway design, and would need to be coordinated and incorporated as necessary.  One coordination meeting with Drainage PER study consultant is anticipated to facilitate coordination of the respective studies (PER).

     Engineering Summary Letter

The Engineer will prepare an engineering summary letter (including CD) summarizing the proposed improvements, including copies of the conceptual designs, design criteria,  preliminary right-of-way determinations, utility inventory, utility impacts, and preliminary construction cost estimate based upon the diagrammatic layout design.

 

The following items will be completed for the project under this scope of work:

1.   Drainage letter report

2.   Diagrammatic layout

3.   Engineering summary letter

TASK 3 – CATEGORICAL EXCLUSION

 

The work to be performed for this task shall consist of providing services required for preparing a Categorical Exclusion, agency coordination, and assistance with a public meeting.  The project consists of providing turn lanes at isolated locations along the project corridor.  Additional right-of-way (ROW) for the turn lanes will be required.  All work to be performed under this contract shall be subject to review and approval by City of Sugar Land, the Texas Department of Transportation (TxDOT) and the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA).  The Engineer will provide the overall project supervision, management, administration and coordination.

 

The Engineer will study the existing environment within the proposed project area.  This will include information from data collection and field investigations by environmental specialists. The Engineer will document the environmental impacts of the proposed project.  Impacts to be addressed will be in accordance with applicable state and federal guidelines. 

 

CATEGORICAL EXCLUSION TASK DESCRIPTIONS